Do Blind People Dream? Why "Is It in Colour?" Is the Wrong First Question
Ask most sighted people about the dreams of someone born blind, and the first question comes out in a flash: do they dream in colour? It is a natural question, and it quietly gives the game away. It assumes a dream is a film, and that the only open matter is whether the film is in black and white or colour. But a dream is not a film. It is a world, built overnight by a tireless set designer who has one strict rule: he can only work with materials you have actually lived. Hand him light, and he builds pictures. Take the light away from birth, and he does not stop building. He simply reaches for different tools.
Do People Born Blind Dream in Colour? The Short, Honest Answer
The short answer is no, and the reason is simple. Colour is a visual sensation, and a person who has never had one has nothing to remember, replay or recombine. Several careful sleep-laboratory studies, among them work by Berger, Olley and Oswald in 1962, Amadeo and Gomez in 1966, and Kerr, Foulkes and Schmidt in 1982, along with a study of home dream reports by Hurovitz and colleagues in 1999, found that people blind from infancy do not have visual imagery in their dreams. The scholars Kerr and Domhoff summarise it plainly: no stored pictures, no pictures dreamed. That does not make these dreams poorer. It makes them different in kind, which is the part worth understanding.
What Do Blind People Dream With? Sound, Touch, Smell and Taste
So what fills the dream? In 2014, Danish researchers led by Amani Meaidi, publishing in the journal Sleep Medicine, studied 50 adults: 11 blind from birth, 14 who lost their sight later (after the age of one), and 25 sighted people. About 70 percent of the blind participants reported touch in their dreams, compared with 45 percent of the sighted. About 86 percent reported hearing, against 64 percent. The gap grew wider when only the people blind from birth were counted, who also reported more taste and smell. Their dreams were built from voices, music, textures, scents and flavours. It is a full world. It just does not run through the eyes.
A Dream Made of Voices, Footsteps and Textures: What It Might Feel Like
Imagine, then, and I say "imagine" on purpose, because none of us can truly enter another person's dream. Picture a dream in which a staircase is something you feel under your feet, a doorway is a change in the echo of the room, and your mother is not a face but a voice and a particular smell of cooking oil and cotton. There is no picture of her, and no need for one. You know she is there with the same certainty a sighted dreamer has when a figure in a dream "is" a friend, even if the face looks nothing like him. Dreams have always been more about knowing than seeing.
Can People Born Blind Ever "See" in Their Dreams? The Scientific Debate
Here the science gets honest and a bit messy. In 2003, a Portuguese team led by Helder Bértolo claimed that congenitally blind people have visual content in their dreams, pointing to dream drawings and to a dip in occipital alpha brain waves during dreaming. Kerr and Domhoff criticised the claim in 2004, arguing that visual images were being inferred from reports and drawings, when blind people can orient themselves in space without any visual experience. They noted that blind dreamers often use words like "visualize" simply to describe awareness of a dream setting. More recent work, including a 2023 systematic review, suggests such imagery, if it occurs, is very rare. The weight of the evidence is clear. The edges remain an open question.
Born Blind vs Lost Sight Later: How Dreams Change With the Age of Blindness
The story changes with the date of loss. People who become blind in adolescence or adulthood often keep visual imagery in their dreams, colour included, because their brains still hold a library of seen things to build from. Meaidi's team found that among the late-blind, the longer a person had been without sight, the less visual their dreams tended to become, as if the library slowly fades. People who were visually impaired from birth but kept some perception of brightness and colour can match their dream pictures to what they see awake. A cut-off near age five is often cited for early blindness, though it is better read as a gradient than a line.
Why the Brain Builds Dreams From Experience: The Set Designer at Work
This is the point where the set designer earns his keep. The leading view, as Kerr and Domhoff describe it, is that dream imagery draws from past sensory experience and stored memory. Nothing visual in storage, nothing visual on the stage. And the brain of a person born blind is not sitting idle. In a famous 1996 Nature study, Norihiro Sadato and colleagues showed that the primary visual cortex of blind people becomes active when they read Braille, and later work found it also responds to sound and spoken language. The studio that would have made pictures has been rented out to other senses. Whether those same regions play a role in blind dreaming is still unknown.
Nightmares in Congenitally Blind People: Why Fear Looks Different
One finding in Meaidi's study stood out. The congenitally blind group reported nightmares at around 25 percent, against about 7 percent in the late-blind group and 6 percent among sighted controls, and the gap held even after the researchers accounted for poorer sleep quality, which is common among blind people. The nightmares they described were not mysterious: getting lost, being hit by a car, falling into a manhole, losing a guide dog. These are real threats of waking life, met with courage every day. The authors suggested that the dreams reflect actual dangers, a reminder that dreams tend to rehearse what we truly worry about, whether or not we can see.
Dreams, Emotion and Memory: What Blind Dreamers Share With the Sighted
For all the sensory differences, the human core of these dreams looks familiar. The Danish study found that blind and sighted participants reported about the same number of social interactions, successes, and failures in their dreams. Love, embarrassment, ambition, and the odd sense of being late for something you cannot name show up on both sides. And here is a quiet surprise for sighted readers: your own dreams also lean on touch and sound, as the sighted group's own numbers show. Vision is the loudest sense in a dream, not the only one. Blind dreamers just let us hear the others without the noise.
The Limits of the Evidence: What We Cannot Know About Blind Dreaming
A fair reader should ask how much weight all this can carry. The Danish study included only 11 congenitally blind participants, and almost everything we know comes from what people remember and report after waking, shaped by the words they have for it. That is true of all dream research, but it matters more here, because words like "see" and "visualize" mean different things to different people. It is also worth being careful with tidy claims in popular articles. The honest summary is that the main pattern is well supported, while the details, especially the rare cases of visual-like imagery, are still being tested.
The Better Question: How Does a Mind Build a World Without Light?
So, with or without colours? Without, for people blind from birth, in the ordinary sense of the word. But the better question asks what a mind does when it must build a whole night's world from sound, touch, scent and feeling, and the answer is that it does it well. These dreams are not a faded copy of ours. They are the same ancient human act, simulating a world to live in it, carried out with different tools. Next time someone asks whether a blind person dreams in colour, the answer could be: they dream in the senses they live in, and the dream is no smaller for it.
This piece is for general awareness. Dream research relies on self-reports and small samples, so findings may change as new studies appear.
References
- http://phenomena.nationalgeographic.com/2014/02/26/how-the-blind-dream/
- https://www.sleepfoundation.org/dreams/can-blind-people-dream
- https://jcsm.aasm.org/doi/10.5664/jcsm.10026
- https://www.researchgate.net/publication/369244170_Dreams_in_Blind_individuals_A_mystery_of_brain_and_vision
- https://spacedaily.com/d-a-blind-person-who-loses-their-sight-before-the-age-of-five-may-dream-mostly-without-visual-images-drawing-instead-on-sound-touch-smell-and-emotion-a-pattern-that-suggests-how-far-the-dreaming-br/
- https://dreams.ucsc.edu/Articles/kerr_2004.html
- https://www.researchgate.net/publication/232482746_Do_the_Blind_Literally_See_in_Their_Dreams_A_Critique_of_a_Recent_Claim_That_They_Do
- https://www.researchgate.net/publication/10623184_Visual_dreams_in_the_congenitally_blind
- https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10605848/
- https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10347682/
- https://www.researchgate.net/publication/14593325_Activation_of_the_primary_visual_cortex_by_Braille_reading_in_blind_subjects
- https://www.nature.com/articles/38278
- https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1014818108
- https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9648859/
No comments:
Post a Comment
Please Share Your Thoughts...